Schmidt: Reasons I liked him: He's funny and fun to hang out with, he's attractive, he's "cool" and I thought he was too good for me but he seemed to like me anyway. We hung out at my house on Monday evening. He greeted me with an enthusiastic hug and then we sat around chit-chatting and watching TV. We also became somewhat intoxicated.
After at least 2/3 of a Pixar film, I basically insisted we make out; he obliged. However, perhaps because of the intoxication and late-night-ness of the moment, or perhaps because one or more of us wasn't that into it, or who knows what, the making out was not nearly as fun as it was the first time :(. Anyway, we hung out til late and then I kicked him out. The following afternoon, I received a text from ol' Schmidty saying, and I quote "Hey sorry if I was bein weird last I'm just kind of a mess/have been kind of a mess lately." I responded saying that I was sorry to hear that, and, if he's ok with it could he please explain why he was a mess. He replied with what should have been incredibly predictable, "Just the usual ex stuff. Shitty cliche but accurate." Pshhh. The end.
Michael Cera: I never fully described my Shy Canadian but he really doesn't require any description. After a brief coffee date and a depressing movie date, MC asked me out for dinner. I replied with,
"Hey MC, thanks for the invite but I'm not actually interested in going out again. It was nice to meet you!"
I find in situations like this it is less painful for all involved to rip the rejection bandaid right off rather than the slow peel of repeated blowing-off and eventual ignoring. Still, I always feel like a bit of a douche when I send these texts. Well, MC pushed me right on over into feeling like a full-on-douche. He replied with,
"That's disappointing and a bit unexpected, but I appreciate your unambiguous response."
Well played, sir. Very direct and also a bit unexpected.